Skip to main content

The M Fell Off

"Ms. Cimini! The M fell off!" When I heard that I thought the kids were joking.  My response was something like "So, there's an M just floating in the water?" I went over to investigate and sure enough, there was an M floating in the water.  Somehow, the M had come off the M&M intact and was just floating there. Everyone stared at it for a moment, took a few pictures then went back to dissolving M & Ms for science. Chemistry was happening. It was fun, fascinating and the students were learning.
The M fell off (look between the O and L)

Last year, I taught middle school chemistry for the first time.  I had taught regents chemistry years before and in teaching middle school chem for the first time I fell to a lot of the bad habits I had developed when teaching high school.  There were a lot of Power Points and worksheets. But this is my year of trying new things. This year I wanted to teach chemistry in a way that was going to make the kids excited to come to class and excited to talk about chemistry. So, I started my planning with an internet search and lo and behold I found an awesome chemistry unit from the American Chemical Society (  It was very detailed, included lesson plans, worksheets, readings, was hands-on and used fairly cheap materials.  Perfect! I was able to pick and choose what I wanted to teach them and in what order.  And the kids loved it. And I loved it.

Here's what I learned (both the science and the pedagogy):

  • Why sugar is soluble in water but not in mineral oil.  The short explanation is that water is a polar molecule.  This means that parts of it have a negative charge and parts have a positive charge.  Sugar is also polar.  When these two polar substances are mixed together, the polar water pulls the polar sugar molecules away from one another and the sugar disperses in the water.
  • Getting kids to understand this is WAY harder than I ever expected.  And every time I thought they were getting it, the assessments smacked my I'm-an-awesome-teacher ego down a peg or two.
  • Kids like learning about chemistry. And they love doing chemistry even more.  This one I knew already but it was a great lesson to learn again.  
  • I have a lot more to learn about chemistry before I can be truly efficient at teaching it.  Chemistry is hard to teach to kids because they can't see most of what you are talking about.  Getting a 13 year old to visualize something that is too small to be seen is a monumental feat (one that I have only partially achieved).
  • As fantastic as this treasure trove of online resources was for this unit, I have some work to do to make it work best for my students and myself.
  • I need a way better end of unit project.  I had the students profile from a household object like shampoo or lotion.  They has to research the chemistry of the ingredient.  They were interesting to read but I kept wondering what they did to tie my unit together and what the students got out of them.  I think that end of unit project is going to need some reworking.
  • Oh, and I learned that I don't really want to know why the M fell off and didn't dissolve with the rest of the candy coating.  I think I may not want to eat too many M&Ms after that.
  • Also, I need to figure out more teacher demos that involve setting things on fire.  Man, the kids LOVE when set things on fire, but then again, don't we all?
So, overall, a positive experience for students and myself but a long way from perfect!


Popular posts from this blog

A Teacher or an Educator?

I hope that I am an educator and not a teacher.
Let me go back a few steps.This past week I watched a very good friend of mine give her first TEDx talk on her experiences throwing out grades (and she rocked it!). This event also featured several student speakers.All the students were fantastic – well spoken, poised and passionate in their delivery. They had a lot of great things to say but two of those things stood out for me.One student talked about the experiences of students working hard to create projects that only the teacher sees.This has sparked in me a tiny revolution but I am going to go into that further in another post.This post focuses on the talk of a young man named Timmy, a senior in high school, who counted off the number of teachers he’d had over the years that he considered educators and not just teachers. As he went on to elaborate about what made a teacher an educator, I just kept thinking, “I wonder if he would call me an educator and not a teacher”.
What makes s…

Creating Opportunities

No matter how hard I work, I am never going to get a promotion. I will never get a bonus. If I want a promotion I have to go back to school (even though I am already 30 credits beyond my master's) and take a job that is no longer in a classroom. Working directly with students is why I got into teaching and I'm not ready to leave that behind. So, according to the definition, I am in a dead end job. I can work my butt off, create fantabulous lessons, give all I have to my students and next year be in the same position making essentially the same money.

Every four or five years I have a teaching crisis of faith. I question what I am doing and why. I think about the other things I could be doing with my life (though as I get older some of those other options are becoming much less likely - I don't think NASA wants to send me to space or that my career as a rock star is going to take off). This most recent crisis was the "I will never get promoted" crisis. Right now, …

Musings about Rubrics

If you are reading this you probably know what a rubric is. If you don't, here's the quick and dirty. A rubric is a grading guide that is available to students. It tells them how their work is going to be evaluated and allows them to evaluate themselves. Rubrics can take many forms. Here is one I recently used with my students:

In our school, as of this year, we grade on mastery grading system. There are 4 "grades" a student can get: Mastery with Excellence = you understand it so well you can teach it to others Mastery = you get it exactly as well as you should Approaching Mastery = you are almost at mastery but not quite there Not Yet Mastered = New to a skill or no where near mastering it
Now, I don't know if this is the case with all mastery schools, but in our school we are all about the rubric. Not only are there project rubrics (which I have always had a hate hate relationship with) but we also have unit rubrics.  There are rubrics for standards and rubrics for…